The controversy over Christianity Today’s editorial calling for President Trump’s removal from office has refocused attention on the role of religious leaders in politics.
There are a variety of opinions on how churches and pastors should engage in the political scene. If at all.
Some pastors use their pulpits for driving specific agendas, parties, and candidates. Others choose to stay out of the political arena.
Must religious organizations restrict their discussion of issues during election campaign periods? No.
“The political campaign intervention prohibition does not restrict discussions of issues that are not linked to support for or opposition to candidates, The Pew Forum Report said. “That candidates may align themselves on one side or another of an issue does not restrict the ability of religious organizations to engage in discussions of that issue. That said, a religious organization may violate the political campaign intervention prohibition if it communicates preferences for or against particular candidates as part of its issue discussions.
Voice of Christian Liberties put it this way:
“Pastors may speak from the pulpit to encourage the members of his congregation to become active in every aspect of the political process and to pray for elected officials as often as he chooses. The pastor may lead the congregation in praying for elections as long as the prayer is not a direct or indirect endorsement of any candidate or party.”
We are not saying there is no space for political discussion. But to use the church pulpit for advancing personal political views or to expand one party is out of line.
This view is not popular in some states. We can disagree. But let’s think about it. Will people gain political choices through Bible teaching? Yes.
Let’s use abortion as an example. All parties have a stand on the abortion issue. One party rejects abortion, and the other approves. But pastors teaching the scripture — training congregations to think biblically and not sway them politically — will give congregants the ability to arrive at their own decision.
Pastors should teach and train their congregations to come to their own decisions
Outside the pulpit, pastors have every right to protest and stand up for what they believe. Pastors are people too. It is also acceptable for them to support and stand against issues that are anti-scripture or morally wrong. But because of the influence they have over their congregation, it is best to share their views by the use of scripture, not their personal bias.
Here is how Christianity Today links the two:
“We should address political issues when the texts of Scripture clearly articulate it. They shouldn’t bow to any party’s talking points. They shouldn’t slant their sermons to fit a political profile. They shouldn’t become wannabee pundits in the pulpit. They should preach the Word and let it do its work in the hearts of the people, who will then go influence their communities.”
What about the concern that a politically silent pulpit caters to the agenda of secularists?
Research Shows Clergy in a Quandary
Barna spent four years studying religious liberty, politics, and clergy members. The report, titled “Faith Leadership in a Divided Culture” asks important questions about Christian leadership and their role in an increasingly pluralistic society.
The grand majority of people of faith believe that “their faith is a force for good” (88%) and “is essential for society” (75%). In general, people of faith believe that their faith is a positive contribution to society. Similarly, clergy members surveyed by Barna believe that they also have a positive role in society due to their faith.
A full 90% of pastors believe it is their role to help Christians understand how the Bible views specific social issues. And yet 50% of clergy feel afraid to speak out on religious liberty issues for fear of offending someone. And that pressure to stay quiet on political and religious issues doesn’t come from outside the church; The Barna study found that it’s the people in the pews that drive the concern.
To add to the difficulty, 40% of pastors feel pressured to speak out about these same social and cultural issues. Many pastors are walking a tight-rope because some pressures them in the pews to speak out, while being afraid to offend others in the same congregation.
Per the Barna study, the most common topics that pastors feel simultaneously pressured and limited in speaking about include: LGBTQ+ issues, same-sex marriage, abortion, morality, and politics in general.
For church leaders, weighing whether to speak on a political issue can be one difficult balancing act.
We believe the Bible is very clear on most of these issues. And we should teach the scriptures on the topic and not the political stand. Some agree with the scriptures and others disagree.
It’s the primary role of pastors to teach what God says about the issues that cross over into political environments
Our priority as Christians is to love others
When Christians place politics above their Christianity, they position themselves in the wrong posture.
It is acceptable for pastors to carry strong political views
But when we express those views outside of the Christian temperament, we are doing more harm than good.
Asserting our political views from our pulpits and expecting others to accept those views is intolerant. Yes, for all political parties.
Believing we are right on an issue does not make us right.
And to assert our political views above our Christian values is choosing the lesser over the greater.
The main purpose of the pulpit is to empower people in spiritual matters and to train them to think for themselves
This post was first posted at Fox News.